JungleDragon is a nature and wildlife community for photographers, travellers and anyone who loves nature. We're genuine, free, ad-free and beautiful.

Join

Volucella zonaria vs inanis CC-BY-NC various authors Collage I created today (for some other discussion somewhere) using images kindly made available at galerie-insecte.org under a CC-BY-NC license.<br />
<br />
The two species can look very much alike. Usually the dorsum of the pronotum is darker and duller on inanis and lighter and more shiny on zonaria, but the shine is difficult to use, especially on photos in bright sunlight or when a flash is used. Male zonarias usually have the pronotum as dark as in inanis and darker females also occur and in inanis lighter specimen are known, so the colour of the pronotum is helpful but not fully diagnostic it would seem.<br />
Same seems to go for the colour of the 2nd tergite (dorsal abdomen plates): Normally more orangy-brown in zonaria, and bright yellow in inanis, but fairly variable and hence difficult to use as &quot;fully&quot; diagnostic.<br />
Best character for ID is the colour of the 2nd sternite, but many, many photos are dorsal only, so this won&#039;t show.<br />
Helpful in dorsal images is the little dark spot that inanis has about halfway down the wing and near the front, but it is not always clear. The zonaria bottom left has a darkish-&quot;shade&quot;(?) there too, which could be a shadow or an underdeveloped true spot. In this case a lateral image was available, so we know for sure it was zonaria, but from the dorsal image I wouldn&#039;t want to confirm it, based on my current laymen&#039;s state of understanding.<br />
If anyone has more ideas that are helpful in dorsal images please DO tell :o) Hoverfly ID help,Syrphidae,Volucella,Volucella inanis,Volucella zonaria Click/tap to enlarge

Volucella zonaria vs inanis CC-BY-NC various authors

Collage I created today (for some other discussion somewhere) using images kindly made available at galerie-insecte.org under a CC-BY-NC license.

The two species can look very much alike. Usually the dorsum of the pronotum is darker and duller on inanis and lighter and more shiny on zonaria, but the shine is difficult to use, especially on photos in bright sunlight or when a flash is used. Male zonarias usually have the pronotum as dark as in inanis and darker females also occur and in inanis lighter specimen are known, so the colour of the pronotum is helpful but not fully diagnostic it would seem.
Same seems to go for the colour of the 2nd tergite (dorsal abdomen plates): Normally more orangy-brown in zonaria, and bright yellow in inanis, but fairly variable and hence difficult to use as "fully" diagnostic.
Best character for ID is the colour of the 2nd sternite, but many, many photos are dorsal only, so this won't show.
Helpful in dorsal images is the little dark spot that inanis has about halfway down the wing and near the front, but it is not always clear. The zonaria bottom left has a darkish-"shade"(?) there too, which could be a shadow or an underdeveloped true spot. In this case a lateral image was available, so we know for sure it was zonaria, but from the dorsal image I wouldn't want to confirm it, based on my current laymen's state of understanding.
If anyone has more ideas that are helpful in dorsal images please DO tell :o)

    comments (2)

  1. Fantastic work again, Arp, these kind of highly visual guides is exactly what we need! Posted 7 years ago
    1. Thanks Ferdy, I don't do flies much so it's mostly convenient for _myself_ to have it at hand somewhere for future reference ;o) Posted 7 years ago

Sign in or Join in order to comment.

No species identified

The species on this photo is not identified yet. When signed in, you can identify species on photos that you uploaded. If you have earned the social image editing capability, you can also identify species on photos uploaded by others.

View Pudding4brains's profile

By Pudding4brains

Attribution Non-Commercial
Uploaded Jul 18, 2018.