JungleDragon is a nature and wildlife community for photographers, travellers and anyone who loves nature. We're genuine, free, ad-free and beautiful.

Join

Musang luwak/Javan Palm Civet, Paradoxurus musangus ssp javanicus - Juvenile  Asian palm civet,Geotagged,Indonesia,Paradoxurus hermaphroditus,Summer Click/tap to enlarge Country intro

Musang luwak/Javan Palm Civet, Paradoxurus musangus ssp javanicus - Juvenile

- No description given -

    comments (4)

  1. I'm not sure what to make of the species. I read the following on Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradoxurus):

    "Asian palm civet comprises three major clades that should be recognized as separate species: namely one in the Indian subcontinent and Southeast Asia (as Paradoxurus hermaphroditus sensu stricto), one in Sumatra, Java and other small islands (Paradoxurus musanga), and the third in the Philippines and the Mentawai Islands (Paradoxurus philippensis). Genetic data, however, do not support species level distinction."

    It seems to basically be saying that genetic studies don't support Paradoxurus musanga as being a separate species.

    IUCN lists Paradoxurus musangus as a synonym of Paradoxurus hermaphroditus, rather than as a separate species:
    https://www.iucnredlist.org/species/41693/45217835

    ITIS lists it as a subspecies of Paradoxurus hermaphroditus:
    https://www.itis.gov/servlet/SingleRpt/SingleRpt?search_topic=TSN&search_value=621985#null

    Although, iNat has Paradoxurus musangus as it’s own species:
    https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/854000-Paradoxurus-musangus

    Plus, there seems to be confusion as to whether it is Paradoxurus musangus or musanga.

    So, is it it’s own species, a subspecies, a synonym? I have no idea.

    Posted 2 years ago
    1. Thanks for taking the time to research it. Seems a "depends on whom you ask" kind of deal.

      Normally, I consider iNat to be pretty trustworthy and typically also most up-to-date, albeit at times opinionated. In any case they are clear on it being musangus, not musanga, scroll to bottom of this page:
      https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/854000-Paradoxurus-musangus

      The seemingly more neutral gbif also supports Paradoxurus musangus, which they consider a synonym for the subspecies Paradoxurus hermaphroditus subsp. musanga.
      https://www.gbif.org/species/11001339

      So it's weird, a synonym between two taxon levels: species and subspecies. That would make Paradoxurus musangus ssp javanicus impossible as that would make it a sub species of a sub species.

      For now, hope you're OK to go with "Paradoxurus hermaphroditus", as we already have a record for it.
      Posted 2 years ago
      1. That is weird, lol. Thanks for looking into it further! Posted 2 years ago
  2. For information, Musang Luwak can be found around my yard which is located in Sukabumi, West Java - Indonesia and usually comes out at night. This young musang luwak was found this morning, possibly left behind by its mother. It's up to you whether to use the name Asian Palm Civet or Javan Palm Civet. Javan comes from the word of Java, so in my opinion it is more suitable to use the name Javan Palm Civet or Musang Luwak. Thanks Posted 2 years ago

Sign in or Join in order to comment.

The Asian palm civet, also called "toddy cat", is a small member of the Viverridae family native to South and Southeast Asia. In 2008, the IUCN classified the species as Least Concern as it is tolerant of a broad range of habitats. It is widely distributed with large populations that in 2008 were thought unlikely to be declining.

Similar species: Carnivorans
Species identified by Ferdy Christant
View SUGIAN1212's profile

By SUGIAN1212

All rights reserved
Uploaded Mar 8, 2023. Captured Mar 3, 2023 16:54 in 4QM6+V9V, Jl. Palasari, Sundawenang, Kec. Parungkuda, Kabupaten Sukabumi, Jawa Barat 43357, Indonesia.
  • Canon EOS 5D Mark IV
  • f/18.0
  • 1/197s
  • ISO400
  • 100mm